This is where I track all my reviews of scientific manuscripts.
This website contains all reviews by Lukas Röseler. The record is almost complete from Summer 2024. Every review is published openly. You can read each one directly here. Feel free to use the website code to track your own reviews openly (MIT licensed): https://zivgitlab.uni-muenster.de/lroesele/reviews
So far, I co-authored around 25 papers (~12 first authorships) and wrote ~30 reviews. According to the rule to review at least 3 times as much as you publish, I am far behind. Thus, do not hesitate to reach out if you would like me to review a preprint or paper for you on the following topics: replication, reproduction, preregistration, open scholarship, scholarly-led publishing, meta-analysis, data sharing, anchoring, status quo bias, or judgment and decision making.
Recommended citation (APA 7)
Röseler, L. (2026, September 16). Open Review Tracker [Website]. https://lroesele.zivgitlabpages.uni-muenster.de/reviews
Manuscript Review Overview
| Date | Journal | Reviewed Work | Round | Inv→Rev (days) | Recommendation | Review | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| September 2026 | RSOS | The Fragility Principle: Quantifying When Scientific Conclusions Depend on Analytical Choice | Round 1 | 33 | Reject | Read review | |
| September 2026 | PCI-RR | Adaptation of Healthcare Services for Home-Dwelling Individuals with Dementia: A Programmatic Registered Report Using National Registry and Caregiver Data ↗ | Round 1 | 4 | — | Read review | |
| July 2026 | Behavior Research Methods | Anchoring-Based Causal Design (ABCD): Estimating the Effects of Beliefs ↗ | Round 1 | 19 | — | osf.io ↗ Read review | also posted on pre-review; https://zenodo.org/records/21281802 |
| July 2026 | Journal of Comments and Replications in Economics | Heterogeneity, not opportunism, is what organizes results from a replication of “Self-interest and fairness: self-serving choices of justice principles” | Round 2 | 21 | — | osf.io ↗ Read review | |
| May 2026 | RSOS | The Fragility Principle: Quantifying When Scientific Conclusions Depend on Analytical Choice | Round 1 | — | Reject | osf.io ↗ Read review | also posted on pre-review |
| February 2026 | PCI-RR | How do Journal Editors Make Decisions About Adopting Open-Science Related Policies or Reforms in their Journal? | Round 1 | 0 | Revision(s) | osf.io ↗ Read review | |
| February 2026 | Journal of Dynamic Decision Making | The influence of cognitive load on the anchoring effect in facial attractiveness | Round 1 | 0 | Revision(s) | osf.io ↗ Read review | |
| December 2025 | JOPD | — | Round 1 | — | — | osf.io ↗ | Deadline extended due to christmas break |
| May 2025 | Meta-Psychology | Reality Television Shows Focusing on Sexual Relationships and College Students Engagement in One-Night Stands: A Replication Report | Round 1 | 14 | Revision(s) | osf.io ↗ Read review | |
| May 2025 | Journal of Comments and Replications in Economics | Heterogeneity, not opportunism, is what organizes results from a replication of “Self-interest and fairness: self-serving choices of justice principles” | Round 1 | 2 | Revision(s) | osf.io ↗ Read review | |
| March 2025 | — | Can I trust this paper? ↗ | Round 1 | 4 | — | osf.io ↗ Read review | Independent review for a preprint |
| January 2025 | Royal Society Open Science | The Reproducibility Promotion Plan for Funders - A co created set of recommendations to foster reproducible research practices ↗ | Round 1 | — | — | osf.io ↗ Read review | Deadline extended due to christmas break |
| October 2024 | CODECHECK | — | Round 1 | — | — | zenodo.org ↗ | |
| August 2024 | Ethic Review (institutional) | — | Round 1 | — | — | — | |
| May 2024 | JASNH | Linguistic Complexity Use Among Female Graduate Psychology Students | Round 1 | 0 | Major revision | osf.io ↗ Read review | |
| April 2024 | Ethic Review (institutional) | — | Round 1 | — | — | — | |
| November 2023 | RSOS | Exploring Open Science Practices in Behavioural Public Policy Research | Round 1 | — | — | osf.io ↗ Read review | |
| March 2023 | Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology | Revisiting representativeness classic paradigms: Replication and extensions of nine experiments in Kahneman and Tversky (1972) | Round 2 | — | — | osf.io ↗ Read review | |
| October 2021 | Meta-Psychology | — | Round 1 | — | — | — | incomplete record until 04/2024 |
| August 2021 | Current Psychology | — | Round 2 | — | — | — | incomplete record until 04/2024 |
| May 2021 | Current Psychology | — | Round 1 | — | — | — | incomplete record until 04/2024 |
| May 2021 | Current Psychology | — | Round 1 | — | — | — | incomplete record until 04/2024 |
| n/d | Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology | — | Round 1 | — | — | — | incomplete record until 04/2024 |
| n/d | Meta-Psychology | — | Round 1 | — | — | — | incomplete record until 04/2024 |
Diamond Reviewer Pledge
I am one of the initiators of the Diamond Reviewer Pledge, that is, I commit to reviewing for a diamond open access at least once a year. Moreover, I decline to review for journals from commercial publishers in most cases and post my reviews on PREreview if there is a preprint available. I recommend to journals to make preprint availability and data + code sharing mandatory for submissions (unless data cannot be shared for ethical or legal reasons).
Previously on OSF
This repository is a continuation of an OSF project where I used to collect everything. It now lives at my institutional GitLab, with potential Zenodo snapshots going forward, because the OSF Projects service is being discontinued.
Original OSF project: Röseler, L. (2026, September 16). Reviews. https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/PBNW7